
Turning Thelma & Louise into a musical was always going to be a tricky one. Ridley Scott’s 1991 film is built around movement, freedom and two women quite literally driving away from the lives they know, so bringing that same feeling onto a stage without the open road or its famous Thunderbird is a big ask.
The new musical had its world premiere at the Young Vic, with original screenwriter Callie Khouri returning to the story, Neko Case providing the music and lyrics, and Trip Cullman directing. Amy Lennox stars as Thelma alongside Rachel Tucker as Louise, taking on the roles made famous by Geena Davis and Susan Sarandon in the 1991 film.
Lennox and Tucker are both excellent, and the friendship between them is one of the strongest parts of the show. Lennox gets a lot of the lighter, funnier moments early on as Thelma starts to let go a little, but she also handles the change in the character really well as the story gets heavier. Tucker gives Louise a steadier presence and brings a lot of emotion to the scenes where you start to see what she is carrying underneath everything. They are both fantastic singers too, and some of the best moments come when the two of them are sharing the stage, because you really believe in the bond between Thelma and Louise.
The supporting cast are strong too. Trevor Dion Nicholas brings a lot to Hal, the detective following the pair across the country, while Jordan Luke Gage has plenty of fun as JD. The whole company throws themselves into the material, and the energy from the cast was definitely there throughout.
Taking the Road Trip to the Stage
The production also looks great. Christine Jones and Brett J Banakis give the stage an Americana-inspired bar setting, with neon signs, warm lighting and the live band sitting above the action. Natasha Chivers’ lighting does a lot of the work when it comes to creating movement, with sweeping lights and flashes across the stage helping suggest roads, headlights and speed without ever putting an actual car in front of us.

I really liked the staging, and there are some lovely visual moments throughout, but the story does lose some of that sense of movement you get from the film. So much of Thelma & Louise is about these two women constantly moving forward, and there are moments on stage where everything feels a little more static.

That also affects the pacing in places. The musical follows the film pretty closely, and some scenes take longer to get through once the songs and ensemble numbers are added in. There were a few points where I wanted things to move a little faster, especially as everything starts closing in on Thelma and Louise.
Neko Case’s country-rock score suits the world of the story well, and there are some great live-band moments, especially when the production lets itself become a bit louder and more concert-like. The vocals are excellent across the board, although I did come away wishing there were one or two songs I could instantly remember afterwards. The performances stayed with me more than the individual numbers did.
Amy Lennox and Rachel Tucker Make It Work
Whenever it comes back to Thelma and Louise together, that is where I enjoyed the show most. Lennox and Tucker are so good together and completely sell that friendship, which is obviously such a huge part of the story. You believe that these two women know each other inside out, you believe the loyalty between them, and that makes the bigger emotional moments hit a lot harder. They really carry the show, and for me, their performances are easily the best thing about it.

That connection also seemed to work with the audience around me. There were plenty of laughs throughout, and the show received a big response at the end, with most of the audience on their feet for the cast. Whatever reservations I had about parts of the adaptation, there is no question that the performances connected with people in the room.
For CultureCues, I really enjoyed Thelma & Louise. Amy Lennox and Rachel Tucker are fantastic, the singing is brilliant and I loved a lot of the staging, but there are moments where you miss the movement and freedom that made the film feel so exciting. Translating a road movie to the stage without the road or the car was always going to be difficult, and you can feel that at times. Still, there is a lot here I liked, and with two brilliant leads, I was more than happy to go along for the ride.
CultureCues Rating: ★★★½☆ (3.5/5)
Nikki Murray is a UK-based writer, screenwriter and founder & editor of CultureCues, covering film, television, music and pop culture. Her work focuses on storytelling and the moments shaping modern entertainment.